The power of when – book review

By Bastian Groiss

I have two critical issues with the book: The power of when

a) the central circadian controller is light – the amount of information on light in this book is minimal at best

b) the focus of this book is 75% on the four chronotypes that Dr Breus created himself, for which almost no scientific references are cited (because they do not exist)

Circadian rhythms are species-wide, with minimal differences within a species. And when significant differences occur, they go along with circadian disruptions and an eventual decline in health. What I saw recently exemplifies this nicely: picture a rat in the middle of the day on a sunny lawn. The poor rat was stumbling along in a haze, obviously very confused and ill. No surprise, as rats are nocturnal creatures. We are diurnal. Our biology evolved around the movement of the sun. This is controlled by the light signal we receive through our eyes and our skin. The master clock in the brain is governed by light received through photoreceptors in the eye. When and what light you see sets the time for everything else to organise around. Everything else is a secondary input—for example, peripheral clocks in your gut, which are set by when you eat. 

My point is that you cannot talk about circadian rhythms without discussing and understanding light in some depth. Indigenous people rise before/around sunrise, and their sleep varies according to the season [1]. Think longer days with shorter nights in summer and longer nights and shorter days in winter. Why? Because of the light and temperature changes. 

Night owls only really exist within modern societies that are bathed in artificial light. When researchers took a group of proclaimed night owls camping for seven days without any artificial light source, their circadian rhythms moved closer to the movement of day and night as they naturally went to bed earlier and woke up earlier [2]. In other words, humans living under conditions of natural lighting physiologically adapt to the length of the day [3].

This shift in sleep/wake patterns is not surprising as artificial light sources are high in blue light while red and infrared light is mostly absent. It is the blue light part of the light spectrum that the photoreceptors in your eye are most sensitive to. This is why artificial light (think LEDs, fluorescents, mobile phones, computers etc) is the leading circadian disruptor that messes with your hormones, sleep and health. [4]

Without reducing and blocking artificial light, especially at night, you will majorly disrupt your circadian rhythms. The other part of the equation is getting more natural light exposure during the day, especially in the morning. It is no secret that seeing the sunrise consistently is by far the most important thing you can do for your circadian rhythm integrity. When living by this natural rhythm, the difference in sleep/wake patterns between so-called night owls and early birds becomes minimal. The same goes for the coined chronotypes dolphins, lions, bears and wolves. Such a distinction is helpful if you do not change your light environment. In that case, you will see improvements following “your chronotype” schedule. But this schedule is far from optimal, as your circadian rhythms will still be majorly disrupted unless you take the sun as your guide and learn about light.

When you start your day after sunrise, you miss out on nature’s wake-up call and the hormonal boost of adrenaline and cortisol that the increasing amount of blue light at sunrise provides. 

In short: the book makes some good points on circadian rhythms in general but entirely misses crucial information on light and managing one’s light environment, all the while focussing on a distinction of four so-called chronotypes that have hardly any bearing in the scientific literature, nor in a natural setting.



[1] Yetish, Gandhi et al. “Natural sleep and its seasonal variations in three pre-industrial societies.” Current biology : CB vol. 25,21 (2015): 2862-2868. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2015.09.046

[2] Stothard, Ellen R et al. “Circadian Entrainment to the Natural Light-Dark Cycle across Seasons and the Weekend.” Current biology : CB vol. 27,4 (2017): 508-513. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2016.12.041

[3] Emens, Jonathan S. et al. “Circadian Rhythms: The Price of Electric Light”. Current Biology vol. 27,4 (February 20, 2017): PR144-R145. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2017.01.014

[4] Grubisic M, Haim A, Bhusal P, Dominoni DM, Gabriel KMA, Jechow A, Kupprat F, Lerner A, Marchant P, Riley W, Stebelova K, van Grunsven RHA, Zeman M, Zubidat AE, Hölker F. Light Pollution, Circadian Photoreception, and Melatonin in Vertebrates. Sustainability. 2019; 11(22):6400. doi:10.3390/su11226400

How to get started with Circadian

Where and how you begin your Circadian journey depends on your situation. Yet as unique as your health, context, and environment is, you will benefit from greater alignment and a better support structure. That structure and the foundation of your health, now and in the future, is your daily rhythm. And the more your rhythm […]
read more

Circadian rhythms and shift work – the ultimate guide

Shift work (aka a changing schedule) is the very definition of circadian disruption. Changing your rhythms throws off your body's timetable. It takes longer than you imagine for your body to adjust to a disruption in your circadian rhythm. For example, one night of shift work can reduce your cognitive capabilities for a week.
read more

Natures rhythm to the rescue

Every species is dialed in and takes its cues from nature on when to sleep, wake, hunt, reproduce, migrate, hibernate, etc. The sun and the rotation of the Earth essentially dictate the rhythm of all life on our planet. The only species arrogant enough to disconnect from nature's rhythm are hairless apes.
read more